A month ago, my colleagues, Bob
Goodlatte, Chris Cannon, Tom Campbell, and I introduced the Technology
Worker Temporary Relief Act that increased the number of skilled
temporary foreign H-1b workers by 45,000.
Today there is still no objective,
credible study that documents a shortage of American high-tech
workers. The Department of Commerce says it does not know if there is
a shortage. The study that Congress commissioned by the National
Science Foundation is not scheduled to be completed until after we
adjourn this year. In the private sector, two substantive non-profit
studies concluded that it is unclear whether there is a shortage.
What is new is that two weeks ago the
INS informed us that demand for these visas is running 50,000 ahead of
last year. In addition, the INS reported that the number of visas the
INS approved last year above what the law allowed was more than
21,000.
So, there is obviously a significant
growth in demand for foreign high-tech workers.
Such demand can indicate any of the
following: An actual shortage, a spot shortage, a preference for cheap
labor or replacement workers, or something else.
Given the importance of the high-tech
industry to our economy, I think we should give the industry the
benefit of the doubt and accommodate the current level of demand.
The new Temporary Worker Temporary
Relief Act I am introducing today will set no limits on the number of
skilled temporary foreign workers we admit during the next three
years. Let the market determine how many foreign skilled workers we
need rather than have Congress set limits based on arbitrary numbers.
This bill responds generously to the
immediate temporary needs of the high-tech industry and also includes
provisions that are good for American workers.
It will require companies applying for
these visas to show they have increased their number of American
employees and increased compensation to American employees.
This bill requires employers to file
public reports on skilled temporary foreign workers they have hired,
what jobs they’ve been assigned to do, and the wages they are paid.
Since these are foreign workers who are
filling what could otherwise be Americans’ jobs, it is appropriate
the American public knows what the industry is doing.
This legislation also sets a floor on
wages for these workers--$40,000 per year. The industry has said that
it uses these workers to fill critical positions in their workforce.
This wage is a good starting point for any high-tech professional.
This bill also requires full
implementation of the 1998 American Competitiveness and Workforce
Improvement Act before the additional visas are available in 2001 and
2002.
Strong anti-fraud measures are
necessary to address known abuses. This bill requires skilled
temporary foreign workers to be full-time employees, requires
employers to have assets of at least $250,000, eliminates the
substitution of work experience for a degree, and provides for checks
of foreign educational institutions that award degrees to these
workers.
These common sense provisions that
benefit American workers and reduce fraud are essential to any
workable H-1b visa bill.
Finally, this legislation addresses
only a small part of America’s future workforce. Ninety percent of
all future jobs will require more than a high school education.
Tragically, 35 percent of legal immigrants, more than 300,000
annually, lack this essential qualification.
If we have learned anything from the
debate over the demand for more skilled temporary foreign workers, it
is that our current legal immigration system is failing us. It
provides large numbers of workers with no skills but does not provide
the high-tech workers we do need.
Every day that Congress debates
temporary foreign workers is a warning that we need a legal
immigration system that better serves America’s interests.