Overview
In a November 10, 2026 memorandum titled “Returning Merits-Based Considerations to PTAB,” USPTO Director John A. Squires announced that PTAB panels will once again decide whether to institute IPRs and PGRs based on the merits. Effective November 16, 2026, the Director will continue to review non-merits considerations, but any petition that passes that review will be referred to a three-member PTAB panel to complete the institution decision. The memorandum directs panels to apply five guidelines that emphasize a petitioner’s burden to support each challenged claim and permit denial when that showing is deficient for a substantial majority of the claims.
The Earlier Institution Framework
Under the March 26, 2025 “Interim Processes for PTAB Workload Management” memorandum, institution decisions were bifurcated: the Director decided discretionary considerations, and PTAB panels decided merits-based considerations. The October 17, 2025 “Director Institution of AIA Trial Proceedings” memorandum then centralized all institution decisions, including merits-based considerations, in the Director’s office.
The Director set out the rubric for discretionary denials in a precedential decision, Magnolia Medical Technologies, Inc. v. Kurin, Inc., IPR2026-00097, Paper 17 (Director May 14, 2026). According to the memorandum, parties have adapted to that framework: in June 2025, about 60% of petitions were discretionarily denied, while in September 2026, only 15% were discretionarily denied.
The November 10 Memorandum
The memorandum supersedes the Director Institution Memorandum to the extent that a petition passing the Director’s initial review will again be referred to a three-member PTAB panel, which will decide, on the Director’s behalf, whether to institute.
The memorandum directs PTAB panels to apply five guidelines, which it describes as “illustrative and not exhaustive”:
- For any prior art ground, a petitioner must explain how the prior art discloses or renders obvious each limitation of each challenged claim. Merely pointing to an examiner’s findings is insufficient.
- If a petitioner fails to make the requisite showing for a substantial majority of the challenged claims, the PTAB will deny institution.
- If a patent owner’s preliminary response raises “a reasonable argument, well-supported with reliable, credible evidence,” that the petitioner fails to meet the institution standard for a substantial majority of the challenged claims, the PTAB will deny institution.
- The PTAB will likewise deny institution if it determines on its own that such an argument exists for a substantial majority of the challenged claims.
- If the arguments for and against unpatentability of a particular claim are both reasonably supported (i.e., in equipoise) for a determination under (2), (3), or (4) above, the PTAB will not view the petitioner as having met the institution standard for that claim.
Panel institution decisions need only briefly address the merits-based considerations the panel found important, and need not address every ground or argument. If a PTAB panel institutes review, a different panel, with no overlapping judges, will conduct the trial.
Takeaways
The memorandum returns delegated decisional authority over merits-based institution issues to three-member PTAB panels, but the guidelines formalize a framework centered on the petitioner’s burden. Petitioners should present a complete, element-by-element case for every challenged claim and should not rely on examiner findings alone. Because failure to make the requisite showing for a substantial majority of the challenged claims leads to denial, petitioners should also consider carefully which—and how many—claims to challenge.
Patent owners gain a meaningful tool in the preliminary response: a reasonable, well-supported argument against a substantial majority of the challenged claims can defeat institution. In assessing whether the petitioner has failed to make the requisite showing for a substantial majority of the challenged claims, the panel will treat an evenly balanced dispute concerning a claim as failing the institution standard.
Parties with pending petitions should determine whether the Office has already entered a notice referring the proceeding for merits-based consideration, because the new process applies only if no such notice has been entered.