Overview
The recent election of Democrats to the Texas governor's office and the Fifteenth Court of Appeals raises questions about the future of the Texas Business Court and the state's evolving business-law landscape. Changes in judicial appointments and appellate leadership could influence developing precedent and the predictability of business litigation as well as create uncertainty about Texas as a business-friendly forum. But despite that uncertainty, several recent statutory reforms are now firmly in place, and we expect Texas and its Business Court to remain an attractive forum going forward.
Background: The Texas Business Court's Role in Business Litigation
The Texas Business Court is a specialized trial court created to hear complex business disputes. It is a separate statutory court with appointed judges who must have significant business litigation, business transactional, or civil judicial experience, and it is designed to issue written, reasoned decisions in complex commercial cases.
The most forward-looking evidence of the Business Court's success is the use of forum-selection clauses. In our recent Texas Lawyer article, we explained that companies are increasingly naming the Texas Business Court in purchase and sale agreements, M&A and reorganization documents, financing and investor-rights agreements, and corporate bylaws.
The Fifteenth Court of Appeals is the statewide intermediate appellate court that hears Business Court appeals and civil cases involving the State of Texas, state officials, state agencies, and challenges to state statutes or rules where the Attorney General is a party. Because most appeals involving the State of Texas will come before this court before reaching the Supreme Court of Texas, the election of new justices may matter most for how challenges to state policy and executive action are resolved under incoming Governor Gina Hinojosa, rather than for disputes between private businesses.
Post-Election Implications for Businesses
Companies have been choosing Texas, but the immediate impact from the election, in our view, is uncertainty. Texas has spent the last several years building a business-law ecosystem: the Business Court, the Fifteenth Court of Appeals, statutory corporate-law reforms, and a broader pitch that Texas is a serious alternative to Delaware and other business-friendly states. A change in governor and appellate bench introduces uncertainty into that pitch.
For instance, how will Governor Hinojosa's administration treat business? That remains to be seen. But Delaware and New York, both led by Democrats, remain home to a large share of the nation's incorporated and headquartered businesses.
Another question: does this shift make Texas less attractive to businesses? It could if businesses conclude that the court system is becoming politically unstable or less predictable. But if the Business Court and Fifteenth Court continue deciding cases promptly, fairly, and with reasoned written opinions, we believe Texas will remain attractive. The key is not whether the judges were appointed by a Republican or a Democrat. The key is whether businesses believe the forum is competent, efficient, and predictable.
Texas Business Court Appointments: Change May Take Time
This election will likely matter over time because Business Court judges are appointed by the governor with Senate advice and consent. However, it does not necessarily mean the Business Court changes overnight. Governor Abbott reappointed the current Business Court judges in July 2026 for two-year terms beginning September 1, 2026. Those appointments were made while the Senate was not in session, so they still must go through the constitutional confirmation process. In the meantime, the current judges remain lawful recess appointees unless and until the Senate rejects them, someone else is confirmed in their place, or the regular session ends without confirmation. The first ten days of the session starting in January 2027 are important because that is the window for submitting nominations to the Senate. There are several ways this could play out.
1) Governor Abbott could submit the current judges to the Senate before he leaves office, and the Senate could confirm them. If that happens, they would continue serving through the current term ending in 2028.
2) If Governor Abbott does not submit the current judges before leaving office, Governor Hinojosa could nominate different people during the remaining portion of the ten-day window. Those new nominees would still need Senate confirmation.
3) Governor Hinojosa could decide to submit or support the same judges. If the Senate confirms them, they would remain on the court through the current term ending in 2028.
4) The Senate could reject either the current judges or any alternative nominees. If that happens, Article IV, § 12 says the offices become vacant and the governor must continue making nominations until someone is confirmed. In that scenario, we believe the current recess appointees would not simply hold over indefinitely, but how that would play out is unclear.
5) The Senate could simply take no final action during the regular session between January and May 2027. In that event, the unconfirmed recess appointees or nominees would be treated as rejected when the regular session ends, the offices would become vacant, and Governor Hinojosa could then make recess appointments, subject to confirmation at the next Senate session.
Would Governor Hinojosa make major changes to the Business Court's composition? Possibly, but we would expect any governor to be deliberate here given the Court's early success and momentum. The Business Court's credibility depends on appointing judges who understand complex commercial litigation and who command confidence from both plaintiffs and defendants. The statute itself requires at least 10 years of relevant business litigation, business transactional, or civil judicial experience. If the new governor appoints judges who are experienced and perceived as fair, the court can remain attractive even if the political party of the appointing governor changes.
The Fifteenth Court of Appeals: Developing Precedent Under a New Bench
The Fifteenth Court could change faster than the Business Court because all three initial Republican-appointed justices lost in the 2026 election. That matters because the Fifteenth Court is the exclusive intermediate appellate court for Business Court appeals, and it also hears important statewide public-law and state-agency cases. We would not assume that a change in party label automatically means a dramatic change in every area of doctrine. Appellate courts remain bound by statutes, precedent, standards of review, and the Supreme Court of Texas. But any difference in judicial philosophy could matter in close cases, and the Fifteenth Court's docket includes the kinds of cases where interpretive approach has an impact: constitutional challenges, state-agency disputes, emergency relief, mandamus practice, and Business Court appeals involving corporate governance.
The biggest impact may be on developing precedent. The Fifteenth Court is still young, and a new bench can influence how the law develops, even if it is operating within statutory limits and Supreme Court precedent.
Future appointments to the Fifteenth Court could be important because they would affect a court with statewide jurisdiction over public-law disputes and exclusive jurisdiction over Business Court appeals. Additionally, Governor Hinojosa will have a direct role in shaping the court's next stage through two additional appointments she can make in her term as the Fifteenth Court expands to five justices.
Texas's Position as a Business-Law Destination
Could the election and the ensuing changes cause companies considering a move from Delaware to rethink? Some may. Delaware still has the advantage of deep precedent and a long-established Court of Chancery. Texas's Business Court is obviously newer and more exposed to changes in statewide politics. Still, the near-term legal framework is more durable than the election headlines alone might suggest. As we outlined in a September 2026 article, recent statutory changes include a codified business-judgment-rule presumption, the ability for qualifying corporations to adopt a derivative-standing threshold of up to three percent of outstanding shares, and time-limited procedures for early judicial determinations of director independence. Those rules are statutory, and major legislative revisions would still have to move through a Legislature in which the Senate remains under Republican control. As a result, Texas's business-law framework may evolve through appointments and appellate precedent, but it is unlikely to change legislatively in the immediate term.
It's possible that the election results may slow Texas's momentum in the short term by introducing uncertainty. But it also provides a proving ground for the Texas Business Court. If the Court remains fast, serious, and predictable under different political leadership, that could actually strengthen Texas's claim that it has built a durable business-law forum rather than a statutory experiment.
**
This article follows a recent interview that Jarod Stewart and Brent Hanson conducted with Law360. Please click here for the full Law360 article.